Search This Blog

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

GPS Bullets and the Fourth Amendment

The BBC reports that police in several states, including my home state of Iowa, are using "GPS bullets":

The bullet is designed to make high-speed chases safer - enabling the authorities to track suspects without having to risk theirs or others' lives. 
And in true spy fashion the system works by hitting a button inside a police car. 
That triggers a lid to pop up releasing a bullet that shoots out and sticks to the car in front.

In United States v. Jones, the Supreme Court held that attaching a GPS device to a vehicle and monitoring its movements was a search under the Fourth Amendment even though the observations could all have been made by simply following and observing the vehicle's public movements.  The tactic was a search because it involved a trespass upon the defendant's property.

One possible critique of drawing direct analogies to Jones facts is that the case only dealt with a GPS device on a car, leaving courts and prosecutors with room to interpret the trespass rationale in other cases.  Police use of GPS devices to track cars seems to be a fairly specific factual scenario.

But as this technological development illustrates, however, the use of GPS devices may be getting easier for police.  While shooting a GPS bullet during a high speed chase would likely be lawful due to exigent circumstances, the vehicle exception, or some other rationale, that bullet's attachment to the vehicle would still probably constitute a trespass-based search, and widespread use of these bullets could raise numerous, interesting Fourth Amendment questions.

As a disclaimer, the BBC also reports that it costs $5,000 to install a GPS bullet system, and each of these GPS bullets costs $500.  This may hinder truly widespread use of these bullets until technological advancement makes them easier to purchase.

No comments:

Post a Comment